Symmetry energy of strange quark matter and tidal deformability of strange quark

Jian-Feng Xu• Cheng-Jun Xia • Zhen-Yan Lu• Guang-Xiong Peng •Ya-Peng Zhao

Abstract Research performed during the past decade revealed an important role of symmetry energy in the equation of state(EOS)of strange quark matter(SQM).By introducing an isospin-dependent term into the quark mass scaling, the SQM stability window in the equivparticle model was studied. The results show that a sufficiently strong isospin dependence CI can significantly widen the SQM region of absolute stability, yielding results that simultaneously satisfy the constraints of the astrophysical observations of PSR J1614-2230 with 1.928 ± 0.017 M⊙and tidal deformability 70 ≤Λ1.4 ≤580 measured in the event GW170817. With increasing CI, the difference between the u, d, and s quark fractions for the SQM in β-equilibrium becomes inconspicuous for C ＞0, leading to small isospin asymmetry δ, and further resulting in similar EOS and structures of strange quark stars (SQSs).Moreover,unlike the behavior of the maximum mass of ud QSs, which varies with CI depending on the sign of the parameter C, the maximum mass of the SQSs decreases monotonously with increasing CI.

Keywords Symmetry energy · Strange quark matter ·Strange stars · Tidal deformability

1 Introduction

At sufficiently high baryon number densities, strange quark matter (SQM) [1-4] with deconfined u, d, and s quarks is expected to be the true ground state of quantum chromodynamics (QCD). Owing to its possible implications in many fields,e.g.,nuclear physics,astrophysics,and cosmology, it has garnered significant attention in the last few decades. Theoretically, SQM is a system dominated mainly by strong interactions, which can be studied in detail using QCD.Unfortunately,owing to the well-known quark confinement phenomenon at relatively low densities,which could be relevant to neutron-star interiors and quark stars,naive perturbative QCD calculations of SQM are not reliable [5].In addition,although the ab initio lattice QCD calculations were very successful in the finite-temperature regime with a zero chemical potential (baryon number density), they still suffer from the famous intractable Fermion sign problem [6]. Therefore,researchers typically resort to phenomenological models,such as the density-dependent model [7-11], quark cluster model [12, 13], quasi-particle model [14-18], Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model [19], and so on. In Refs. [20, 21],strong magnetic field effect on the properties of SQM had been investigated, and numerous interesting results have been obtained in other studies [22-25].

To study the SQM properties using phenomenological models, one of the most important issues is determining reasonable values of the model parameters. Given the conjecture that SQM is absolutely stable, the most commonly used constraint is that, for SQM, the energy per baryon should be smaller than 930 MeV,while for the bulk u-d quark matter (u-d QM) it should be larger than 930 MeV. Moreover,significant progress has been made in the observations of global properties of compact objects, such as mass, radius, and tidal deformability. For example, the measurements of PSR J1614-2230 and PSR J0348+0432 several years ago precisely determined masses of 1.97 ±0.04 M⊙[26] (a more precise mass measurement yielded 1.928±0.017 M⊙[27]with a 68%credible level)and 2.01± 0.04 M⊙[28], respectively. In addition, the more recently measured gravitational mass of PSR J0740+6620 reached 2.14M⊙with 95.4%credibility,likely making it the largest compact star observed up to date [29] (the updated result for PSR J0740 + 6620 is 2.08M⊙[30]with 68.3% credibility). Therefore, these observations of pulsar masses have been widely used to constrain the EOS of compact stars and the onset of the phase transition from hadronic matter to quark matter in hybrid stars [31, 32].

In addition, with the coming of multi-messenger observations of neutron stars, owing to the detection of gravitational waves for events GW170817 [33] and GW190814 [34], additional stringent constraints on the EOS of compact star matter have been appeared [35-37].Specifically, it was determined that for GW190814, the newly discovered compact binary merger possesses a secondary component with mass as large as 2.50-2.67 M⊙at the 90%credibility level.If it is confirmed to be a compact star,rather than a light black hole,it will be possible to rule out many EOSs. Moreover, this detection of gravitational waves for GW170817 offers a novel opportunity to directly probe the properties of matter under extreme conditions found in the interior of compact stars, yielding improved estimates of tidal deformability Λ1.4=190+390-120[38]. This measurement of tidal deformability has been widely used for constraining the properties of compact star matter[39-46].

Recently, an interesting proposition was made, suggesting that, instead of the SQM, the u-d QM may be the true ground state of QCD [47]. According to this proposition, it has been found that the properties of the u-d QS are in accordance with various astrophysical observations[48],where quark symmetry energy effects are included in the EOS of the u-d QM.In practice, it has been found that symmetry energy plays an important role in determining the properties of isospin asymmetry matter [49-53]. For nuclear matter, although the symmetry energy behaviors have been well determined below and around the saturation density,it remains a big challenge to determine the density behaviors of the symmetry energy at suprasaturation densities, where phase transitions of strong interaction matter may occur,and various new forms of matter may appear.In fact, due to the different symmetry terms in different phases, isospin effects are rather significant [54]. In this study, considering the isospin effects of the SQM, we investigated the stability window and symmetry energy of SQM and employed some of the constraints mentioned above in the equivparticle model [23] to examine whether the SQS properties are consistent with the reported astrophysical observations. It is found that inter-quark isospin effects are necessary for reconciling the SQSs obtained in the equivparticle model with the aforementioned constraints.

The remainder of this paper is organized as follows.Section 2.1 briefly describes the equivparticle model,

where quark mass scaling with isospin effects is introduced. Then in Sect. 2.2, the equations for calculating the tidal deformability of compact stars are presented. In Sect. 3,the numerical results of the properties of SQM and the structures of SQSs are given and discussed.Finally,we conclude this paper with a brief summary in Sect. 4.

2 Equations for symmetry energy and tidal deformability

2.1 Equivparticle model with isospin asymmetry

where mi0is the quark current mass, D is the confinement parameter indicating the linear confinement effect, C represents the one-gluon exchange interaction for C＜0 and the leading-order perturbative interaction for C ＞0, and parameter CIi(CIu=CId，CIs=0)is used for adjusting the strength of the isospin-dependent equivalent quark mass and thus the magnitude of the quark-matter symmetry energy.In addition,this equivalent quark mass satisfies the exchange symmetry between u and d quarks in quark matter in the absence of inter-quark electromagnetic interactions.

The energy density and pressure of the SQM are,respectively, given as

Using Eqs. (9) and (10), Eqs. (14) and (15) can be considered as a set of equations for ρuand ρd.By solving these equations for a given ρb, we obtain ρuand ρd, and then,accordingly, the EOS of the SQM.

There are two methods for obtaining the symmetry energy. The first approach uses the parabolic law,approximately given by [56, 57]

where ν is the quark Fermi momentum of the symmetric ud QM at the quark number density. ρ=2ρu=2ρd.

According to Eq.(18),Eq.(17)can be explicitly written as

We found that the discrepancy between the symmetry energies given by Eqs. (20) and (22) is essentially negligible. Therefore, in the following calculations, we adopted Eq. (20) to calculate the SQM symmetry energy.

2.2 Equations for calculating structures and tidal deformability of SQSs

To calculate the structures and tidal deformability of SQSs, we briefly introduce relevant equations. To obtain the SQS structures, one should numerically solve the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkov (TOV) equation:

where ∊s is the energy density difference between internal and external regions.

3 Numerical results and discussion

To study the isospin effects on the EOS of the SQM and the SQS structures, the values of the model parameters should be designated. First, the current masses of quarks are given as mu0=5 MeV,md0=10 MeV,and ms0=100 MeV. If Eq. (20) is used for computing the symmetry energy,the values of the up and down quark current masses are mu0=md0=7.5 MeV.The values of the parameters C,D, and CIare determined by studying the SQM stability window,combined with the astrophysical observation data of both massive compact star PSR J1614-2230 with 1.97±0.04 M⊙and tidal deformability 70 ≤Λ1.4≤580 measured for GW170817.

Shown in Fig. 1 are the SQM stability windows for different CI,with the value labeled in each panel.The black solid line in each panel indicates 930 MeV per baryon for the SQM; the SQM becomes unstable if the energy per baryon exceeds 930 MeV. Similarly, the dashed line in each panel corresponds to the 930 MeV (per baryon) level for the u-d QM; below this line, the energy per baryon of the bulk u-d QM is smaller than 930 MeV, and nuclei are likely to decay to the u-d QM. This case contradicts the modern nuclear physics and should be forbidden. Therefore,only the area between the black solid and dashed lines is the SQM’s absolute-stability region.In addition,the blue line in each panel represents the configuration that can yield the maximum SQS mass with 2 M⊙.However, when CIand/or C is negative, and baryon number density is sufficiently large, further decreasing CIwill lead to a negative quark mass and the requirement of maximum mass with 2 M⊙will be no longer satisfied. Therefore, the blue lines in Fig. 1 will end at a certain point that is indicated by a star.The red line indicates the upper limit of Λ1.4=580 measured for GW170817.Moreover,it is worth mentioning that,if we decrease the values of the maximum mass Mmaxor tidal deformability Λ1.4, the lines representing them will shift upward, as indicated in panel(a) with up arrows.

Comparing the three panels in Fig. 1, it is evident that,by increasing the isospin dependence parameter, CI, the dashed line will move significantly downward,whereas the solid line will be barely affected. Consequently, this will widen the SQS stable region. However, comparing panels(b) and (c), it can be observed that, for sufficiently high isospin parameter CIvalues(e.g.,for CI =400 MeV fm3),further increasing it does not affect the absolute-stability region. In particular, we verified that beyond CI10000 MeV fm3, the absolute-stability region barely changed as the value of the parameter was further increased.

By contrast, the blue lines for massive SQSs with 2 M⊙and red lines for the SQS tidal deformability with Λ1.4=580 tend slightly downward as CIincreases, but neither is affected significantly by varying CI. To satisfy these two astrophysical observations (i.e., Mmax=2 M⊙and Λ1.4=580), the cross-points of the blue and red lines should be located in the absolute-stability region. Unfortunately, from these three panels, we can easily observe that, although the cross-point approaches the stable region with increasing CI, it does not end up in the stable region,even for CIvalues as high as 10000 MeV fm3. Given that the absolute-stability region does not change significantly by increasing CIwhen it is already sufficiently large, we conclude that in the equivparticle model with mass scaling as given by Eq.(2),the two observables Mmax=2 M⊙andΛ1.4=580 cannot be simultaneously satisfied by one set of model parameters.

Fig. 1 (Color online) Stability windows for the SQM, for different values of the isospin strength parameter CI. The absolute-stability region between the black solid and dashed lines widens significantly with increasing CI, yielding results consistent with both the astrophysical observations of massive compact star PSR J1614-2230 with 1.98 ± 0.017 M⊙ and tidal deformability 70 ≤Λ1.4 ≤580,measured for GW170817. The blue line denotes the maximum mass of the SQSs with 2 M⊙,the red line represents the upper limit of tidal deformability measured for GW170817, i.e., Λ1.4 =580, and the red line with circles in panel (c) gives the lower limit Λ1.4 =70. The typical model parameters are indicated in panels

However, if we loosen the constraint on tidal deformability to its lower limit, namely decreasing Λ1.4to 70, the red line moves upward to the position of the red line with circles, as shown in panel (c).Therefore,it can be inferred that as Λ1.4decreases,the intersection point of the blue and red lines moves upward along the blue line. Therefore, we can choose the point （C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.6，164.5）indicated by the black dot in panel(c)as one of the typical parameter sets, which is located in the SQM absolute-stability region. For comparison, we select parameter sets（C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.7，168） and (0.08, 139) as typical parameter sets for investigating the SQM properties and the SQS structures, which are, respectively, indicated with a red square and blue diamond in panel (c). To study the effect of isospins on the SQM properties and SQS structures, we also chose points （C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.6，164.5） in panels (a) and (b) as typical model parameter sets indicated by black dots, which are in the SQM unstable region.

Fig.2 (Color online)Density behavior of SQM energy per baryon in β-equilibrium.It is obvious that the minimal energy(circles)for each curve is exactly at the density corresponding to zero pressure(asterisks), satisfying the requirement of thermodynamic consistency

In Fig. 2, the density behavior of the energy per baryon is shown for typical parameters. The figure reveals that in the equivparticle model, the minimum energy (circles) for each curve is at exactly the same density as zero pressure(asterisks), satisfying the requirement of thermodynamic consistency.Moreover,the one-gluon exchange interaction(C＜0) can significantly lower the minimum energy per baryon, which makes SQM much more stable than normal nuclear matter. In addition, comparing the three black lines,we find that with increasing CI,the minimum energy per baryon increases. However, for high values of CI, the difference between the solid black line (CI =10000 MeVfm3) and dashed black line (CI =400 MeV fm3)becomes small. This is because, with increasing CI, the difference between u and d quark fractions becomes small in β-equilibrated SQM, which results in vanishing isospin asymmetry δ. We can examine this point in Fig. 3. With the parameter set （C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.6，164.5）, the quark fractions are expressed as different CIvalues indicated in each panel in Fig. 3. Evidently, the differences between u, d, and s quark fractions become smaller as CIincreases. In particular, for CI =10000 MeV fm3, the difference between the u and d quark fractions is small,which leads to vanishing δ. Additionally, in this case, it is interesting to note that when ρb0.6 fm-3, the u, d, and s quark fractions are essentially equal and approach 0.33,similar to the case of the color-flavor-locked (CFL) phase.The results for the density behavior of quark fractions in this study resemble those reported in Ref. [56].

Figure 4 shows the density behavior of the symmetry energy for typical parameters.From the left panel of Fig.4,it can be seen that the value of C plays an important role in determining the symmetry energy. Generally, for the nuclear matter symmetry energy there are essentially two groups of density behavior, where one increases monotonously with density,and the other first increases and then decreases with increasing density [57, 62]. The latter is typically regarded as soft. Specifically, if the symmetry energy of nuclear matter becomes negative at suprasaturation densities, neutron stars exhibit pure neutron matter cores [63].Similar to nuclear matter symmetry energy, the behavior of the SQM symmetry energy in the present work can be divided into two groups, depending on the value of the model parameter C. For non-negative C, the symmetry energy increases with increasing density.Otherwise,it first increases and then decreases with increasing density,which means that it becomes soft at high densities. However,unlike the nuclear matter symmetry energy, the quark matter symmetry energy in our model does not become negative, because the quark masses given by Eq. (2)become negative at sufficiently high densities with negative C. However, the soft quark matter symmetry energy will affect the chemical composition of the SQS core and may have important implications for the structures and dynamical evolution of SQSs; this issue requires further studies.

Moreover, as will be discussed later, to satisfy the requirement of the two-solar-mass constraint of the SQS maximum mass, the symmetry energies shown in the left panel can be as high as 3500 MeV,as indicated by the solid black line. In addition, in the left panel of Fig. 4 we also show the results from Fig. 1 in Ref. [56]; these are shown here by the red dashed line indicated with DI-300 × 30.The reason for choosing the parameter set DI-300 for comparison was that the SQM symmetry energy with DI-300 is of the same order of magnitude as the nuclear matter symmetry given by the RMF model with interaction NLρδ.Therefore, from this panel, we can see that the SQM symmetry energy is approximately 30 times higher than the nuclear matter symmetry energy, which is consistent with the findings in Ref.[56].In addition,it is interesting to note that at relatively low densities, the symmetry energies shown by the black solid and black dashed lines are indistinguishable. The right panel of Fig. 4 shows that, on one hand,when CI=0,the symmetry energy increases with increasing density, while when CI =400 or 10000 MeV fm3,the symmetry energy first increases and then decreases for densities above 0.4 fm-3; on the other hand, the symmetry energy increases drastically with increasing strength of the isospin dependence parameter CI,e.g.,the symmetry energy for CI=10000 MeV fm3is approximately 20 times that for CI= 400 MeV fm3, or even more than 150 times that for vanishing CI.

Fig. 3 Quark fraction as a function of the baryon number density in the equivparticle model, with the corresponding parameters indicated in each panel. The blue, black, and red lines are,respectively,for the u,d,and s quark fractions.See text for a detailed discussion

Fig. 4 Quark matter symmetry energy as a function of the baryon number density. The left panel shows that for C＜0 the symmetry energy peaks at a certain density.In addition,the red dashed line with DI-300 is replotted from Ref. [56], which has the same order of magnitude as nuclear matter symmetry energy. For the sake of comparison with the presently obtained results, we multiplied it by 30.Therefore, for satisfying the constraints imposed by astrophysical observations, the SQM symmetry energy can be as much as 30 times the nuclear matter symmetry energy.From the two panels we find that by increasing the isospin dependence parameter CI, the symmetry energy can be drastically increased, especially for C ＞0

Fig. 5 Mass-radius relations of SQSs and the relation between the dimensionless tidal deformability and the SQS mass, for different model parameters. The solid black line for the parameter set（C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.6，164.5） and CI = 10000 MeV fm-3 yields the maximum mass Mmax =1.97 M⊙,corresponding to the measured mass of PSR J1614-2230. Although the dashed black line does not reach the maximum mass for the configuration with the model parameter set （C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.7，168） and CI = 10000 MeV fm-3, it yields the maximum mass above 2.01 M⊙, which is in accordance with the observed mass of PSR J0348 + 0432

Left and right panels of Fig. 5 show, respectively, the SQS structures and tidal deformability. The left panel of Fig. 5 shows that, as the isospin dependence parameter CIincreases,the maximum mass and the corresponding radius of the SQS decrease, which is different from some previously reported results [56]. Moreover, although all maximum mass values in the left panel are above 1.93 M⊙,namely, the lower limit of the observed mass of PSR J1614-2230,only the black lines with parametric sets are in the SQM absolute-stability region, which is illustrated in Fig.1.This finding reflects the crucial role of the symmetry energy on the SQM EOS in the equivparticle model.Typically, the black solid line with （C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.6，164.5） and CI= 10000 MeV fm3yields the maximum mass Mmax=1.97 M⊙, corresponding to the measured mass of PSR J1614-2230. In addition, owing to the fact that with increasing SQS central density the quark equivalent mass given by Eq. (2) becomes negative, the dashed black line where （C，D1/2/MeV）=（-0.7，168）does not reach the maximum mass. However, the mass of the most massive star given by the black dashed line can exceed 2.01 M⊙,which is in accordance with the measured mass of PSR J0348 + 0432 [28]. If we constrain the parameters to the SQM absolute-stability region in panel(c)of Fig.1,we obtain that the SQS maximum mass can be as large as 2.02 M⊙in the present model, which is still within the limits of the measured mass of PSR J0740 +6620 with values of 2.08±0.07 M⊙[29].Nevertheless,for GW190814 [34] it was shown that the binary merger possesses a secondary compact object with the mass as high as 2.50-2.67 M⊙at the 90% credibility level, which is far beyond the maximum mass of 2.02 M⊙in the present model.If the secondary compact object is a neutron star or a quark star, this may imply that other inter-quark interactions should be taken into consideration,or a novel quark mass scaling should be proposed for the equivparticle model. Specifically, Table 1 lists the typical quantities and symmetry energy for the SQS core. From Table 1, all the maximum masses shown are approximately 2 M⊙,and with a positively valued model parameter C,the SQS maximum mass yields a lower central density. However, it is worth mentioning that the quark matter symmetry energy at the SQS center for positive C is much higher than that for negative C, although the central density is lower.

The right panel in Fig. 5 shows the relation between the dimensionless tidal deformability and the SQS mass, for the equivparticle model with different parameter sets in Fig.5.The horizontal blue dashed line in the right panel of Fig. 5 corresponds to the SQS with 1.4 M⊙, whereas the two blue solid lines indicate the range of the tidal deformability,that is,70 ≤Λ ≤580,based on the improved analysis of GW170817 using LIGO and Virgo collaboration[38].Note that the tidal deformability increases rapidly as the SQS mass decreases,which means that lighter SQSscan be deformed easier than heavier SQSs.Meanwhile,it is evident that all intersections of the typical lines and the blue dashed line are located between the two solid blue lines. Given the maximum masses in the left panel, the typical configurations with the parameter sets we have chosen in the present model can satisfy both the astrophysical observations of the massive compact star PSR J1614-2230 with 1.97 ± 0.04 M⊙and the tidal deformability 70 ≤Λ1.4≤580 measured for GW170817.

Table 1 With the typical parameters （C，D1/2/MeV）, the maximum mass Mmax, the radius corresponding to the maximum mass R, the central density n0,and the quark matter symmetry energy at the SQS center Esym are listed in the following table

4 Summary

In this study, we investigated the isospin effects on the SQM stability window by introducing an isospin-dependent term into the quark mass scaling to account for thequark-matter symmetry energy and further studied the EOS of the isospin-asymmetric SQM. We found that by increasing the isospin dependence parameter CI, the SQM absolute-stability region becomes significantly wider,therefore enabling support of the massive compact star PSR J1614-2230 with 1.97 ± 0.04 M⊙and the tidal deformability 70 ≤Λ1.4≤580 measured for GW170817.As for quark fractions,we found that with increasing CIthe difference between u and d quark fractions became negligible,yielding vanishing isospin asymmetry δ;in addition,as the baryon number density increases, the u, d, and s quark fractions approach approximately 0.33,similar to the CFL phase results. The symmetry energy properties were then examined by considering different values of CI. It is interesting to note that for C＜0, with increasing CI the SQM symmetry energy first increases and then decreases,implying soft symmetry energy. In addition, the symmetry energy increases drastically with increasing isospin dependence parameter CI, especially for C ＞0. Owing to the widening of the SQM absolute-stability region by incorporating the isospin effects into the SQM EOS, the measured mass of PSR J1614-2230 with 1.97 M⊙and the dimensionless tidal deformability 70 ≤Λ1.4≤580 measured for GW170817 could be well explained as SQSs by choosing proper model parameter values in the SQM absolute-stability region. However, considering that the measured mass of PSR J0740 + 6620 can be as large as 2.08 M⊙, the present equivparticle model still cannot explain more massive SQSs with masses exceeding 2.02 M⊙. This may imply that other SQM effects should be considered, e.g., the presence of u-d quark Cooper pairs(2SC phase)[51],or a novel quark mass scaling framework should be developed [56]. Finally, unlike the SQS maximum mass,which decreases monotonously with increasing CI,the variation in the u-d QS maximum mass is uncertain,depending on the sign of the model parameter C.

Fig. 6 Maximal SQS mass, as a function of CI. Unlike the maximum SQS mass, which decreases monotonously with increasing CI, the variation in the maximum mass of the ud QS is complicated, depending on the sign of the model parameter C

Table 2 With the typical parameters（C，D1/2/MeV）,for the u-d QS maximum mass Mmax,the tidal deformability Λ1.4,and the energy per baryon E/nb are listed in the following table, where CI =104 MeV fm3

Author ContributionsAll authors contributed to the study conception and design. Material preparation, data collection, and analysis were performed by Jian-Feng Xu, Cheng-Jun Xia,Zhen-Yan Lu,Guang-Xiong Peng, and Ya-Peng Zhao. The first draft of the manuscript was written by Jian-Feng Xu, and all authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript.All authors read and approved the final manuscript.